This results in the extensive sackurtetrode equation for entropy. Sackurtetrode equation article about sackurtetrode. Mar 04, 2010 a 15 points derive the sackur tetrode equation for the entropy s su. Oct 18, 2019 the sackurtetrode equation is named for hugo martin tetrode1 18951931 and otto sackur2 18801914, who developed it independently as a solution of boltzmanns gas statistics and entropy equations, at about the same time in 1912. This months column has been contributed by guest author richard williams.
The objective of this study was to highly increase the oxygen barrier performance of pla. By plugging the variables in and solving, it comes very close to the st equation. The sackurtetrode equation is an expression for the entropy of a monatomic classical ideal gas which incorporates quantum considerations which give a more detailed description of its regime of validity. Use the sackurtetrode equation to calculate the entropy. The idea is to measure the increment of entropy a sub.
Hugo tetrode and otto sackur independently developed an equation for the entropy using a solution of the boltzmann statistic. Usage of partition function in derivation of sackurtetrode. Pdf sackurtetrode equation in the lab researchgate. For a derivation of the sackurtetrode equation, see the gibbs paradox. Sackur and tetrode, independently, obtained an equation for the entropy of an ideal gas starting from statistical mechanics. On the sackurtetrode equation in an expanding universe scielo. Section 4 statistical thermodynamics of delocalised particles. Of course this is absurd, so the sackurtetrode equation must be invalid at very low temperatures. I posted the following solution on this board wanting to get opinions of the validity of a solution using only the microcanonical ensemble.
Grimus on the sackurtetrode equation 2011 1, i have studied the hypotheses behind this equation and the way it can be experimentally tested with a calorimetric method. According to the sackurtetrode equation, the entropy of a monatomic ideal gas can become negative when its temperature and hence its energy is sufficiently low. Jul 10, 2017 why do they introduce the partition function. In slowly mixing the two phases, we preserve the total thermal energy. Derivation of sackurtetrode equation physics forums. Sackurtetrode equation the pressure p is v nk t v f p b t or pv nk bt 3. These results can be cast into forms which are easier to remember. These difficulties are further considered and partially settled in appendix b. Polylactic acid or pla is currently considered as one of the most promising substitutes of conventional plastics, with low environmental impact, especially for food packaging applications. Four possible pathways were presented to illustrate the chemical processes. Can you derive sackurtetrode equation entropy for ideal gas. The actual significance of this equation is negligible and can be calculated by multiplying the equation with.
The sackurtetrode equation for the statistical entropy. The system consists of n particles distinguishable. Do not write down your name, just your assigned letter. Oct 14, 2011 you can derive the sackur tetrode equation by solving for the entropy of an ideal gas using stirlings approximation applied to the multiplicity formula. The sackur tetrode equation is an expression for the entropy of a monatomic classical ideal gas which incorporates quantum considerations which give a more detailed description of its regime of validity. This is totally unphysical and it is in violation of the third law of thermodynamics. Pdf an expression for the entropy of a monoatomic classical ideal gas is known as the sackurtetrode equation. For an ideal gas, each particle is independent of the others, and hence the probability.
Physics stack exchange is a question and answer site for active researchers, academics and students of physics. Canonical ensemble we consider a calculation of the partition function of maxwellboltzmann system ideal mb particles. What links here related changes upload file special pages permanent link page information wikidata item cite this page. Used constituents of original to illustrate a system becoming more disordered. Onthe100thanniversaryofthe sackurtetrodeequation arxiv. Derive the sackurtetrode equation physics stack exchange. Gibbs paradox we need to use the sackurtetrode equation for the identical gases ln 2 3 ln t c n v s nk b where c is a constant, and n nn a. Incorrect calculation the partition function for translations of one atom of mass m in a box of volume v is z 1 v2.
The entropy of the system indeed becomes a true extensive quantity. Nov 11, 2011 sure, you just have to add on the entropy for any additional degrees of freedom. Statistical mechanics what you need to know ptcl, oxford. Sackurtetrode equation free expansion no heat, no work, but entropy increases. This model is combined with one for rotational entropy to estimate. If the mass in a system is conserved, it is sufficient to consider the simplified entropy. To calculate the standard molar entropy, s m, set p p in the expression for sm. Toward sustainable plabased multilayer complexes with. If the concentration is increased while holding the temperature. Use the sackur tetrode equation to calculate the entropy of a mole of argon gas at room temperature and atmospheric pressure. I have seen it in the derivation of the boltzmann distribution.
Using newtons 2nd law, compute obtain a di erential equation for the speed of sliding of the rod, and show that v v 0 e t compute the characteristic time 5pt e. According to the sackurtetrode equation, the entropy of. The mechanism of the reaction between char and nitric oxide no on zigzag and armchair edge structures was studied based on density functional theory dft. Of course this problem is all tied up with quantum mechanics and multiple occupancy. Pitp summer school 2009 institute for advanced study. Correct calculation for particles confined to a volume v, the probability density for the location of a particle is 1v. Sackurtetrode equation masatsugu sei suzuki department of. Rather, they are derivatives of the entropy difference ds. The fact that quantum mechanics makes particles eveninprinciple indistinguishable is huge, and it resolves the gibbs paradox, leading to the sackurtetrode equation.
Nevertheless, some drawbacks, such as high permeability to oxygen, are still limiting its industrial applications. Of course, there isnt just one such equation, since it depends on the details of the molecules composing the gas. An equation for the translational entropy of an ideal gas made up of free fermions explanation of sackurtetrode equation. These give a more detailed description of its regime of validity. We have analyzed the latter, since the vapor pressure method relies on this one.
Moreover, we redo the numerics by using modern mercury data in section 4 and obtain a reasonably. Entropy of a classical ideal gas of distinguishable atomsc. To find the chemical potential, we can use another standard relation. On the 100th anniversary of the sackurtetrode equation.
The entropy s of a monoatomic ideal gas can be expressed in a famous equation called the sackurtetrode equation where. Legendre transformations iii, the sackurtetrode equation. Can someone please explain the process of how you derive the sackurtetrode equation from this. Robbing a student of this fact, and the amount of brainwarp that it creates, is not a bad thing necessarily, but its also not necessarily a good thing. Pdf an alternative expression to the sackurtetrode entropy. The sackurtetrode equation gives us some insight into this problem.
The grand achievement in the derivation of this equation was the. Sackurtetrode equation article about sackurtetrode equation by the free dictionary. But i dont know the physical significance of it here. Sackur and tetrode to derive their equation and add some comments. The entropy predicted by the sackurtetrode equation approaches negative infinity as the temperature approaches zero i. The sackur tetrode equation and the measure of entropy francisco jos e panos exp osito volves vapor pressure measurements as well as calorimetric ones 1, 2, whereas the other is purely calorimetric 3. Comprehensive exam i fall2008 afternoon session do all 4 problems. The entropy is given by the sackurtetrode equation. Robbing a student of this fact, and the amount of brainwarp that it creates, is not a bad thing necessarily, but its also not necessarily a. The information constraints youre looking for over the probability distribution of variables are. Comprehensive exam i fall,2000 portland state university. The above equations have general solutions of the form. When the system is mixed, the change of the entropy is.
N number of atoms k boltzmanns constant v volume u internal energy. Compute the rate of decrease of the kinetic energy of the rod per unit volume, and show that it equals the ohmic heating rate dissipated electric power per unit volume. This file is licensed under the creative commons attribution 2. Now that we have an expression for the entropy of a ideal, monatomic gas, we can find the heat. On the sackurtetrode equation in an expanding universe where a atis the scale factor of the evolution, or roughly speaking, the universe radius, so that v a3 varies with the universe expansion.
You can derive the sackurtetrode equation by solving for the entropy of an ideal gas using stirlings approximation applied to the multiplicity formula. The sackurtetrode equation for the entropy of an ideal gas can be written as. Is there a sackurtetrode equation for nonmonatomic gases. Moreover, this concrete example provides one with the opportunity to point out some of the difficulties encountered in an attempt to define algorithmic information content of specific physical systems. Density functional theory study of the role of an carbon. The sackurtetrode equation is named for hugo martin tetrode1 18951931 and otto sackur2 18801914, who developed it.
Sackurtetrode equation for the entropy, s nk ln v 4. The sackurtetrode equation is an expression for the entropy of a monatomic classical ideal. Grimus on the sackur tetrode equation 2011 1, i have studied the hypotheses behind this equation and the way it can be experimentally tested with a calorimetric method. Early in the twentieth century, leading physicists were struggling to get a deeper understanding of the concept of entropy. Sackurtetrode equation for the entropy of an ideal gas. My thermodynamics text does not go through the whole derivation, but that is how it says to derive it. In particular the sackurtetrode equation for the entropy of the ideal gas is also valid in the case of an expanding universe, provided that the constant value that represents the current entropy of the universe is appropriately chosen. On the sackurtetrode equation in an expanding universe.
Pdf a wallfunction approach for direct precipitation. The entropy s of a monoatomic ideal gas can be expressed in a famous equation called the sackur tetrode equation. Sep 22, 2010 this is a retouched picture, which means that it has been digitally altered from its original version. The sackurtetrode equation is an expression for the entropy of a monatomic classical ideal gas which incorporates quantum considerations. Sure, you just have to add on the entropy for any additional degrees of freedom. The sackurtetrode equation and the measure of entropy. Why is the entropy greater than that of a mole of helium under the same conditions. Sackur tetrode equation for the entropy of an ideal gas. Use the sackurtetrode equation to calculate the entropy of a mole of argon gas at room temperature and atmospheric pressure. Motivated by this question, and taking advantage of a previous article by w. From sect 32entropy is related to the dispersal of energy and that the partition function is a measure of the number of thermally accessible states, we can be confident that the two are indeed related. The sackur tetrode equation gives us some insight into this problem. In particular the sackurtetrode equation for the entropy of the ideal gas is also valid in the case of an expanding universe, provided that the constant. The results show that the activation step and the release of carbon monoxide co and carbon dioxide co2 are the controlling steps in the nochar reaction.
Lecture 8 entropy of the ideal gas, entropy of mixing and gibbs paradox, indistinguishable particles, sackur tetrode equation lecture 9 canonical ensemble, energy fluctuations and specific heat, equivalence of microcanonical and canonical ensembles. In the classical lowdensity limit, the absolute entropy s of a monatomic ideal gas can be described by the sackurtetrode equation. N number of atoms k boltzmanns constant v volume u internal energy h plancks constant one of the things which can be determined directly from this equation is the change in entropy during an isothermal expansion where n and u are. The fact that quantum mechanics makes particles eveninprinciple indistinguishable is huge, and it resolves the gibbs paradox, leading to the sackur tetrode equation. Sackur and tetrode were able to devise a test of their equation by applying. Untitled whitesides research group harvard university. If the number of particles n and total particle energy u are. Note that the conjugate forces are zero at equilibrium, analogous to a drag force that depends on. Then explain whether or not the sackurtetrode equation agrees with the third law of. Use the sackurtetrode equation to calculate the entropy of a. Entropy of a classical ideal gas of distinguishable atoms. This problem is a straightforward variation of what we discussed in class for a 3d gas and of two problems that you solved in a recent homework assignment regarding a 2d gas see problems 2. According to the sackurtetrode equation, the entropy of a.
Can you derive sackurtetrode equation entropy for ideal. The lectures are uploaded as pdf files, so you will need adobe acrobat reader in order to read them. Even if one were willing to say that e is a function of t through s, i. The sackurtetrode equation and the measure of entropy francisco jos e panos exp osito volves vapor pressure measurements as well as calorimetric ones 1, 2, whereas the other is purely calorimetric 3. Since historically the corroboration of the sackurtetrode equation by using data on the vapor pressure of liquid mercury was crucial, we give a detailed account of it in section 3. This is the sackurtetrode equation, quoted before in section 3. Calculation of energy, entropy and heat capacity of polyatomic molecules.
311 1151 476 760 585 28 1327 956 1389 895 1556 1571 503 589 1425 1125 1075 1194 796 1380 1167 611 1449 875 374 865 446 1574 1354 792 879 211 460 680 813 105 1055 1523 194 932 939 567 354 1021 384 1324 871 1435 857 1414